Flipping the focus
  • Blog

blog

This discussion forum is being moderated as an expression of servant leadership in teaching & learning. As a collaborative tool for brainstorming enriching experiences for students, teacher learning groups, and district learning teams, we can inspire and build experiences to help empower each of us to personal leadership in learning. Thank you, in advance, for your contributions and leadership to realizing outcomes for improving student achievement, equity and well-being.

FROM THE ARCHIVES

learning to belong; belonging for learning: Improving student learning through culturally-responsive pedagogy

10/18/2018

0 Comments

 
Welcome back to Flipping the Focus.
In the last post, you read how developing and enacting our personal resources to creating community and belonging is critical for student learning and can be done at each level of service--classroom, school, and district.

​Engaging student voice, cycling through inquiry, driving conversations with data, and building coherence between these levels will ensure that we are helping to improve learning for all.
Picture
Belonging: What Might We Do to Culture It?
Despite its complexity, part of the answer lies with us. Agile Leader, ​Simon Breakspear (2015), along with others, have identified that meeting students' needs requires that we, ourselves, engage in professional learning. The goal of this learning is not easily chosen; rather, it is based upon identifying an urgent need--needs determined by analyzing multiple sources of data.

Ask yourself what it is about particular districts where coherence is evident and working. I think you'll find that their professional learning model(s) seek to help educators uncover student needs and engage in inquiry that not only helps them to learn how to best meet those needs but also invites students to co-construct conditions that will improve their chances for success.
Culturing Belonging: Getting Started with Inquiry
Before you move towards identifying a data-informed, urgent need, it's important that you establish a set of team dynamics that will support your model for collaborative inquiry. Figure 1 (below) depicts stages that you can move through with your school learning team(s)/professional learning community.
Figure 1 (Note: There are two hyper-links embedded in the "Yes" branches of the flowchart.)
​Based on the pathways provided in Figure 1, if you know that your team's collaborative dynamics are well-structured and working, I would encourage you and your team to move forward with a sample inquiry and model for professional learning that leverages Student Voice (see link, right).

On the other hand, if you know that it is better for you and your team to take more time to culture collaborative norms, I would encourage you to complete the posted activity in its entirety (below; "Starting with a Values-Causal Model"). 
Student Voice
Starting with a Values-Causal Model 
Author of "Classrooms as Think Tanks: Part 1 - The Values Causal Model," Jennifer Warren (2018) explains that getting to innovative thinking requires that we generate ideas collectively. And it is through this type of thinking that we are better able to solve problems--all of it made possible by being comfortable "[wading] into complexity with confidence." This means that we need to make community-building central to what we do alongside students.
Picture
I-Think Program Model: Values-Causal
Thus, if you want to make thinking the vehicle for improving both student engagement and learning, you might find using a Values-Causal Model beneficial for beginning the work of culturing belonging in your classroom/school. The model, used by Rotman’s I-Think program, allows you to generate insights based on mapping the complexities of an issue. For an explanation of how Warren used this model with her students, read more here and here (Part 2).

How might this work with my Team?

Leveraging a Values-Causal Model with My Team
I have taken inspiration from the model and have created an exercise (see below) that could help you and your team(s) determine what they value most about one another, and further to this, what they value most about teaching and learning. You see, developing a set of shared beliefs is a powerful motivation for teams to collaborate and learn deeply.
​

And with similarities set aside, the real value in this model is its ability to highlight different perspectives. Without these perspectives, it’s impossible to generate better ideas...the kinds of ideas that can lead to efficient and effective, innovative problem solving.
Learning Activity #1-Values-Causal Modeling

​What makes you, you?
Invite, at least, one other person to do this activity with you--either face-to-face or remotely. It can be done asynchronously, provided you make time (in the same day) to go through Parts 1 to 3 of the activity below.
Picture
Part 1
-Grab a piece of paper, leaving the middle open.
-Thinking deeply about it, write out as many items as you can around the middle, open space you’ve left--that is, your responses to the prompt, "What makes you, you?" 
-Take a ‘step’ away from your scribbles…(stay away a bit longer)...now come back to the page. Do you have any additions/revisions you want to make?
-
Might you be able to make links with some of the items you’ve listed? Take some time to do this.
Part 2
-Now come back to the middle, open space. This is you. The middle open, space is a confluence of all of the items you’ve written, along with their connections. Let’s call these items values.
-In that middle space, take some time to fill it with a theme or themes...that is, a representation of you. It can be a word, several words, a picture (or pictures)...the idea is not to over-qualify “you” with a lot of details. Allow the brevity of the small collection of themes to take over.
Part 3
-Reach out to your partner(s).
-Share the representation of “you.” As you listen, do exactly that...give your partner time to fully express their thinking.
-Following their explanation, take a moment to ask clarifying questions (if needs be).
-Switch roles, following the same steps. This protocol, although simple, can help us to listen interpretively as opposed to responsively. The goal is for each of you (and collectively) to stay in a reflective space.
Picture
Part 4-Reflection #1
Now take a moment to consider the following:

Personal:
-Do I “see” my partner(s) differently? How so?

-Do I “see” myself differently? How so?
-What am I feeling from having done this activity?

As Pairs/Whole-Group:
-Having asked your partner, what are they feeling?

-Do you know yourself/partner better than before? Why?
-If you can say that you feel like you belong (relative to the perspectives of your partner), what shared belief(s)/value(s) are bringing you together?

Value-Added Activity: Think of applying this in the classroom...other learning spaces!

Learning Activity #2-Reflecting Through Culturally-Responsive Pedagogy
Either on your own or with your partner(s), go back to the earlier parts of the activity. Apply the following lens(es)/dimensions to qualify some of the items/aspects of your sketch, accordingly. I recommend that you "stay the course" with this final reflection: insights as to how you (and your team) will focus direction for collaborative work will start to emerge. As they do, and without getting drawn away from the activity, take brief moments to document these somewhere, and come back to them later on.

Note: To clarify the meaning of the lenses, a description has been provided for each one (Culturally-Responsive Pedagogy, 2015).
Culturally-Responsive Pedagogy Monograph
The Lenses
​Institutional
  • Reflecting “...values developed and reflected in school board policies and practices…”
Personal
  • Reflecting [your] educator’s mindset “...and the practices [you] engage in, in order to support the development of all students…”
​Instructional
  • Reflecting “...knowing [your] learners well and considering [your] classroom practices which lead to a culturally-responsive classroom."
Why These Lenses?
By integrating these lenses into our thinking...into the way we engage in our professional practice, we come to a deepened sense of understanding of how "culture goes much deeper than typical understandings of ethnicity, race and/or faith.

It encompasses broad notions of similarity and difference and it is reflected in our students’ multiple social identities and their ways of knowing and of being in the world.

In order to ensure that all students feel safe, welcomed and accepted, and inspired to succeed in a culture of high expectations for learning, schools and classrooms must be responsive to culture" (Culturally-Responsive Pedagogy, 2013).

Learning to Belong IS Belonging for Learning

Learning Activity #3: Next Steps - Take Your Learning Further
Now that you've completed this learning activity, work your way back to the flowchart (above) and/or consider what follows.

In order to gain diverse perspectives on creating conditions for transforming student learning, I administered two, on-line surveys to educators. The first, survey prompt was as follows: "What would you consider a pillar for transforming student learning?" Several days later, I followed up with a second prompt--the wording slightly adjusted for greater precision ("What would you consider a pedagogical pillar for transforming student learning?")

Both surveys remain active and are included below for you. As the surveys collect no information but your perspectives, I would like to encourage you (and your teams) to share your beliefs/values from Learning Activity #1, #2 or both.

Once complete, you can also view the results through the links provided below each of the surveys.
Results - Survey 1
Results - Survey 2
From the surveys, notice the different pillars/values are being reported as important to transforming student learning (The relative importance is associated with the font-size of each of the responses. Some of the pillars are duplicated in other words, so there are other values that you can see as having more representation.).

Given this sample of responses, discuss with your partner(s) some of these pillars/values to creating culturally-responsive spaces for student learning. 

-Would you add any of these to your, personal sketch?
-Is the collective graphic missing any pillars you would deem important?
​-How would you rank these in terms of importance to you? How would they rank in importance to your students?

That last question is a key to moving from transactional learning to one that is transformational in service (Dawes, 2018). As you engaged in your own values-causal modeling, interacting with your partner, and the survey, did you find yourself determining these values because of student voice?

Did you find yourself determining values because of Student Voice?

Final Thoughts
In closing, I would like to thank you for working through the learning activities and sharing your insights. I can't help but to think of the deep class and school conversations that can be inspired when we take collective action to improving student learning.


As this blog is a means for readers to network and gradually change the context for how you/your class/school/district operates, we all benefit by drawing nearer to the perspectives shared here and shared beyond with our professional learning networks.
​
I am more than happy to collaborate with you and feature our learning, here, in this blog and across Flipping the Focus' social media platforms (Facebook and Instagram at 
FlippingtheFocus and Twitter @flip4change), as well as those of your own.

Contact Flipping the Focus to see how we can work together towards achieving your/your organization's goals.
Contact
Book Chris
Professionally Yours,

Chris Stewart, OCT
Educational Consultant, Flipping the Focus, (c) 2018

References & Further Reading
References
Culturally-Responsive Pedagogy
  • Ontario Ministry of Education, Literacy & Numeracy Secretariat. (2013). Culturally-Responsive Pedagogy (35th ed., Capacity Building Series, pp.1-8). Retrieved from http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/literacynumeracy/inspire/research/cbs_responsivepedagogy.pdf

Leadership/School Improvement
  • Breakspear, S. (2015). Overview of Learning Sprints [Video blog post]. Retrieved from https://vimeo.com/282261789
​
​Pedagogical Practice
  • Warren, J. (2018, August 13). Classrooms as Think Tanks: Setting the Conditions for a Thinking Classroom Part 1: The Values Causal Model. Retrieved from https://thelearningexchange.ca/classrooms-as-think-tanks-setting-the-conditions-for-a-thinking-classroom-part-1-the-values-causal-model/

School & System - Learning & Change
  • Dawes, P. (2018, April 2). Moving from Professional Development to Professional Learning [Web log post]. Retrieved from https://www.edushift.ca/articles/moving-from-professional-development-to-professional-learning

Further Reading (suggested)
Collaborative Professionalism
  • Hargreaves, A., & O'Connor, M. T. (2018). Collaborative professionalism: When teaching together means learning for all. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin, a SAGE Company.
  • Hargreaves, A & O’Connor, M.T. (2018). Seminar Series 274: Leading Collaborative Professionalism, Centre for Strategic Education, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. Retrieved from http://www.andyhargreaves.com/online-reports--monographs.html 

Data-Driven Improvement
  • ​Barneveld, C., Dr. (2008, August). What Works? Research Into Practice - Using Data to Improve Student Achievement. Retrieved from https://thelearningexchange.ca/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/Dec5DataMonograph.pdf​

Pedagogical Practice - Thinking & Problem Solving
  • Rotman School of Management. (2018). What We Do & Believe. Retrieved from http://www.rotmanithink.ca/what-we-do/
​
Student Voice
  • Ontario Ministry of Education, Literacy & Numeracy Secretariat. (2013). Student Voice: Transforming Relationships (34th ed., Capacity Building Series, pp. 1-8). Retrieved from http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/literacynumeracy/inspire/research/CBS_StudentVoice.pdf

System Learning & Change
  • Fullan, M., & Quinn, J. (2016). Coherence: The right drivers in action for schools, districts, and systems. Thousand Oaks: Corwin.
  • Fullan, M., & Quinn, J. (2016, January). Coherence Making: How Leaders Cultivate the Pathway for School and System Change with a Shared Process. School Administrator, 30-34. Retrieved from https://www.scoe.org/files/Fullan_Quinn.pdf​
0 Comments
    Tweet

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Author

    I am passionate about leadership for learning and teaching and learning through inquiry. Through collaborative exploration of high-yield, pedagogical strategies, I have been able to further engage students to deepen their learning and fellow educators in continuously growing their practice--Flipped Learning, Thinking Classrooms, and culturing Student Voice as examples.  I hope that this site serves you well in your educational journey through teaching and learning by moving professional learning into your time ... your space. If you have questions or feedback, please feel free to contact me. Sincerely, Chris Stewart (OCT).

    Archives

    November 2019
    July 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    August 2017
    June 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    August 2016
    February 2016
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013

    NEW SITE!
    Check out: Flipped PL
    Tweets by @math_inquirer

    Categories

    All
    21c
    3-Act Math Tasks
    3-math Acts
    5 Practices
    6Cs
    Aaron Sams
    Accountable Talk
    Achieving Excellence
    Action Plan
    AEAC
    AJ Juliani
    Alex Overwijk
    Andy Hargreaves
    Assessment As Learning
    Assessment-capable
    Assessment For Learning
    Assessment Loop
    Assessment Of Learning
    Autonomy
    Balanced Instruction
    Bandura
    Basic Skills
    #belong
    Belonging
    BIPsa
    #blendedlearning
    Carol Dweck
    Cathy Bruce
    Chris Stewart
    Christine Suurtamm
    Classroom Discourse
    Classroom Video
    Coaching
    Cognitive Science
    Coherence
    Co Learner
    Co-learner
    Collaboration
    Collaborative Inquiry
    Collaborative Professionalism
    Collective Capacity
    Collective Efficacy
    Colonialism
    Communication
    Conceptual
    Continuing Education
    Conversations
    Co-planning
    Coteaching
    Co-teaching
    Critical Frienc
    Crystal Kirch
    Culturally-responsive Pedagogy
    Cycle Of Inquiry
    Danielle LaPointe-McEwan
    Dan Meyer
    Data-Driven
    David A. Sousa
    David Thomas
    Deeper Learning
    Deep Learning
    Delia Bush
    Descriptive Feedback
    Differentiation
    Digital Footprint
    Digital Leadership
    Digital Portfolio
    #diglead
    Diigo
    DJ Cunningham
    Documentation
    Don Klinger
    Dynamic Learning
    Edadmin
    EDpuzzle
    Education
    Educational Leadership
    Effect Size
    Efficacy
    Elementary
    Emergent Leadership
    EOSDN
    EQAO
    Equity
    Equity Hypothesis
    Executive Functioning
    Feedback
    Flipclass
    #flipclass
    Flipped Classroom
    Flipped Learning
    Flipped Learning Network
    Flipped Pd
    Flipped PL
    Flipped PLN Finder
    Flipping The Focus
    Flow
    Formative Assessment
    Gap Closing
    George Couros
    Global Competencies
    Golden Circle
    GoodNotes
    Google Doc
    Google Forms
    Gratefulness
    Growing Success
    Growth Mindset
    Guest Blog
    Guest-blog
    Guest Blogger
    Guided Inquiry
    @HarnessingA
    Hattie
    Helene Coulombe
    History Of Math
    How Do You Know?
    If-then
    Inclusion
    Inclusive Environments
    Indigenous
    Indigenous Education
    Indigenous Learning Model
    Innovation
    Inquiry
    Insights
    Instructional Core
    Instructional Leadership
    Jaime Depippo
    Jimmy Pai
    Joanie Causarano
    Jo Boaler
    John Hattie
    Jon Bergmann
    Jon Orr
    Junior Math Study
    K-12 IPAT
    Kemptville
    Kemptville Public School
    Ken Leithwood
    Knowing Your Learners
    Kristin Daniels
    Kyle Pearce
    #L2BB4L
    Land Acknowledgement
    Land Treaties
    Leadership
    Learner Profiles
    Learning Cafe-UCDSB
    Learning For All
    Learning Goals
    Learning Partner
    Learning Preferences
    Learning Skills
    Learning Styles
    LearnStyle
    Lesson Study
    Lisa Ain Dack
    Listening
    Long-term Memory
    Lucy West
    Lyn Sharatt
    Macpl 2019
    Marian Small
    Mary Jean Gallagher
    Mastery Learning
    Math Community
    Math Talk
    Meaningful Notes
    Metacognition
    MFM1P
    Michael Fullan
    Microsoft
    Microsoft Forms
    Mindset
    Ministry Of Education
    Monitoring School Improvement
    Monitoring Student Learning
    #MTBoS
    Narrative Feedback
    North Grenville DHS
    Number Strings
    OAME
    OCSB
    Ocsbmath
    OCT
    Office 365
    Onenote
    Ontario
    Ontario's Equity Action Plan
    Parent Engagement
    Parents
    Paul Tough
    PBL
    Pedagogical Documentation
    Pedagogical Learning
    Pedagogical Practice
    Pedagogical System
    Peer-assessment
    Perceptual Data
    Peter Liljedahl
    Phil Dawes
    PjBL
    Place-Based Learning
    Plan-Act-Assess-Reflect
    PLC
    PLN
    Portfolio
    Principal
    Principal As Co-learner
    Problem Of Practice
    Problem Solving
    Procedural
    Process Skills
    Professional Development
    Professional Learning
    Professional Learning Community
    Professionally Speaking
    Project-based Learning
    Queen's University
    Reconciliation
    Reflection
    Reflective Practitioner
    Relational Trust
    Relationships
    Renewed Math Strategy
    Representations
    Residential Schooling
    Resilience
    Responsive Pedagogy
    RMS
    Rola Tibshirani
    Rotman IThink
    Sandra Herbst
    Sandy Pignon
    School Administration
    School Effectiveness Framework
    School Improvement
    School Learning Team
    School Level Leadership
    School-level Leadership
    SE2R
    Self Assessment
    Self-assessment
    Self-confidence
    Seth Godin
    Seven Fallen Feathers
    SIM K 12
    SIM K-12
    Simon Breakspear
    Simon Sinek
    SIPsa
    #sitbeside
    Small School Summit
    Spiraling
    Stanford
    Stephen Hurley
    Steven Katz
    Storify
    Story-Telling
    Student Achievement
    Student Centered
    Student-centered
    Student-centred
    Student Engaged Assessment
    Student-engaged Assessment
    Student Engagement
    Student Improvement Plan
    Students As Researchers
    Students Of Mystery
    Student Survey
    #studentvoice
    Student Voice
    Student Wellbeing
    Student Well-being
    Success Criteria
    Susan Dion
    Susan Scott
    Talk Moves
    Tap Into Teen Minds
    Teacher Efficacy
    Teacher Observation Tool
    Teaching
    TED Talk
    Thinking Classroom
    Third Teacher
    Thought Partner
    Tom Driscoll
    Tools & Resources
    Transferable Skills
    Tribes
    Truth
    UBC
    UCDSB
    #ucdsb
    #ucdsbmath
    University Of Windsor
    Upper Canada DSB
    Values Causal Model
    Values-Causal Model
    Vertical Spaces
    Video Instruction
    Visible Learning
    Visible Thinking
    Vision Of The Mathematics Learner
    Viviane Robinson
    VNPS
    #vnps
    VoicEd Radio
    VRG
    Whiteboards
    Why
    Will Richardson
    Working Memory


    Disclaimer
    ​The discussion, information, and materials provided in this online space do not necessarily represent the opinion of the Upper Canada District School Board (UCDSB), Ontario Association of Mathematics Educators (OAME), Ontario Ministry of Education (MoE), the University of Windsor (Faculty of Education), and their affiliates. This online space is intended to provide its readers and/or contributors with opportunities to learn about and share, respectively, information about teaching & learning. The UCDSB, OAME, MoE, UWindsor, and their affiliates do not guarantee the accuracy and appropriateness of the content posted. Aside from the moderators' posts, Flipping the Focus does not guarantee the accuracy of the comments and/or information posted by contributors. The moderators have the right to remove and will remove any content that they deem inappropriate or offensive. Questions regarding the information posted can be directed to the site's moderators using the contact form provided (below).

      Contact

    Submit
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from g23armstrong, Sebastian Mary, LizMarie_AK, Frontierofficial, US Department of Education, gordontarpley, juanpol